Even the rush of air outside the car was hot. Rather than providing a respite from the heat, cracking the windows was like opening a recently-used oven. A charming quirk about midday Middle Eastern air, I suppose. Here I sat in the backseat of a Mitsubishi, wedged in tightly with two American comrades, taking in the sun-scorched landscape of the Jordan Valley along winding mountain roads. As we pushed further and further away from the major population centers, dusty golden hills laid out endlessly before us, punctuated by Palestinian tents and double-fenced Israeli settlements.
In the front seats were two Israeli women, probably in their mid-to-late twenties, clad in black, one with a camera and one with a notepad. Both carried an air of battle-hardened confidence that suggested they had already been through a lot, both together and separately. If I had to guess at their political leanings I would say they were anarchists, though I didn't ask. People with such determination can be intimidating.
The women were part of an organization called Machsom Watch, a human rights group whose members—all Israeli women as far as I can tell—stand at Israeli checkpoints throughout the West Bank and record what they see. Similar to what Copwatch does in America, Machsom members write reports, take pictures, and record video of the treatment of Palestinians by Israeli soldiers at checkpoints.
I was introduced to one of these women (to be known from here on out as “the writer,” the other will be called “the photographer”) through a contact at ICAHD that recognized our mutual interest in the Jordan Valley. My main project for ICAHD at the moment is the construction of a report on how Israel exercises control over the Palestinians in "Area C" of the West Bank. The Jordan Valley, the large strip of land alongside the river of the same name, comprises the vast majority of Area C and a sizable portion of the West Bank itself. Recently, many villages in the Valley have been issued demolition orders by the Israeli military. Also, some of these rural Palestinians have lost their lives to stray bullets from Israeli military exercises; it seems like gradually the whole area is destined to be composed of either Israeli settlements of "closed military zones."
At an ICAHD meeting a couple weeks ago, I had volunteered to cover the issue since it sounded like a unique, unsung part of the Occupation that would provide good journalistic fodder. But not long after I wondered what I had gotten myself into: the villages are far out, spread out, and I speak virtually no Arabic. Luckily, I was paired with an Arabic-speaking fellow ICAHD volunteer for the assignment, but it didn't (and still doesn't) solve the first two problems.
Finally, though, we had an "in" with people with an interest in the Jordan Valley and their own private car. We were off.
Our first stop was a Palestinian home not more than five hundred meters from an Israeli checkpoint. There we pulled into the rocky driveway and the writer approached the man of the house, who was wearing a keffiyeh the proper way: on his head. A few exchanges in Arabic and before long, we were all sipping coffee and sitting in plastic chairs arranged in a circle. Three children—two boys and a girl, ranging in age from 8-13—sat alongside the father, soaking in the conversation. The oldest boy possessed that fascinating quality that many Palestinian boys have of acting much older than their real age; a contemplative intensity mixed with tactfulness.
During the conversation I sat dumbly and mutely listening to an alien language and the occasional braying of a donkey in the distance. I badly want to learn Arabic. Thankfully I was filled in as we got out of our seats: the family has already had two homes demolished on the property (evidenced by the rubble in the distance), and luckily, has evaded a demolition order for their current house because the structure was built before 1967. Yet they do have a demolition order for their livestock pen; they showed us both the pen and the piece of paper that sentenced it to the same fate as their two previous homes. 



After that was over it was back into the stiflingly hot car and off on the road again. The writer pointed out that these cinder block signs had only recently gone up all over the Valley:
These signs were all placed at the driveways or entrance roads to Palestinian homes. We guessed that perhaps this was the first step in an effort to scare the Palestinians off in order to spare the effort of pushing them off the land. From an apolitical outsider's perspective, it would seem that the Israeli military wants to construct the biggest firing zone in the globe. We pulled into another driveway, this time towards a series of tents opposite a livestock pen. Once again, a few words and we were invited inside.
Although I couldn't participate in the ensuing conversation, I was still quite absorbed. The situation this family lived in was pretty raw. There were five or six small children, two women, and an old man cramped into this tent that was swarming with flies. An infant was asleep on a quilt on the ground (there were no beds), despite that fact that flies were buzzing about her face, crawling on her cheeks and mouth. A bowl of rotting eggplant sat on top of a refrigerator that didn't seem to have any electrical power coming to it. Outside of the tent, an adolescent boy riding a donkey sauntered by, occasionally smacking the animal on its neck with a stiff wooden plank.
Despite their obvious poverty, the family still gave us the remarkable hospitality characteristic of Palestinians. After chairs were provided for us, they all sat on the ground. And before long, a platter with six steaming cups of tea made its way into the tent. Although this family, as it turns out, hadn't received any demolition orders, they lamented the fact that they had to pay exorbitant costs for water—the water supply of Area C is completely controlled by the Israelis (the pumps have barbed wire fences around them). As you may guess, this arrangement has been good for Israeli settlers in the area.Which leads me to our next stop: an Israeli settlement. The Machsom women wanted to see if any growth in the settlement was happening—an issue that not only resonates with local Palestinians, but worldwide. Before we arrived, however, we came across this wonderful oddity on a hilltop nearby.


The photographer muscled the surprisingly resilient car up the rocky slopes, kicking up a massive cloud of dust, until we reached the abandoned tank. No telling the origins of this beast—1948? 1967? Jordanian? Israeli?—but it was fun to look at and pose with nonetheless. Scattered about the ground, weighed down by rocks, were these military-issue cardboard cutouts:
At this point we were right next to the eastern border and could see the hills of Jordan not far off in the distance. We snapped a couple more shots and moved on. As we neared the gate of the Israeli settlement, the Machsom women debriefed us on our new identities: we were just tourists, looking for a health-food store that we had heard about. At the gate, the writer smilingly exchanged Hebrew with the Israeli soldier who stood guard, and we were let in. At that moment I envied the women for being Israeli Jews: the privileges that it allows an activist and a journalist regarding this issue are incredible. Not only does it allow access into places forbidden to most, but it nullifies any allegations of anti-Semitism that have become so common among the increasingly paranoid "defenders" of Israel across the globe.
To be honest, the first homes in the settlement didn't look much different from the trailer parks characteristic of redneck America; there was even a shirtless man standing outside one of them. As expected, there was no shortage of water here—the settlement bloomed with greenery. (My fellow Americans and I learned, as we were driving throughout the parched Valley, to easily identify settlements in the distance by this feature.) As we wound around the trailers, we came upon a construction site with a few men walking about. Bingo.
We feigned wonder and excitement to the builders about the hardened-sandbag structure and soon met a young American from Florida at the site. I asked him how he had gotten here, and he replied that it had been through the World Wide Opportunities on Organic Farms program. "Oh really? What do you grow here?"
"Nothing actually. They just used it [WWOOF] to get people to come out here and help them build." *laughs*
Despite this initial deception, the young man from Miami said he was having a fantastic time, better than he ever could have imagined if he had been actually growing food. As for our own story, it didn't hurt that one of my colleagues is attending Brandeis, a largely Jewish private university. We were just traveling, innocently taking in the beauty of Israel...
Still, I was glad to be gone once we left—I hate having to lie. To quote Mark Twain (who, ironically, had harsh words for Palestinians): "If you tell the truth you don't have to remember anything."
Our last activity of the afternoon was a checkpoint watch – the Machsom women's expertise. Because of Israeli military regulations, we parked at least a hundred meters away from an outpost flying an Israeli flag and what appeared to be – but could not have been – an anarchist flag (I found out that this was the flag used by this particular battalion/unit/whatever you call it) and strolled up towards it.
The soldiers were familiar with the writer and, occasionally flashing looks our way, talked amongst themselves. Meanwhile, Palestinian cars and people trickled through without much problem. This is a perfect example of how an observer, simply by being present, alters the natural state of a system and perhaps gets a false impression of the normal state of affairs. In science, this is plainly called the observer effect.
To put this theory into a concrete framework: Israeli soldiers are much less likely to give Palestinians a hard time when there are possibly influential internationals or fellow Israelis watching; there exists no greater privilege for being white than in the occupied Palestinian territories. Thus, watching the checkpoints is a win-win situation: either the mere presence of a non-Arab watcher allows the Palestinians an easier time through than they would normally get, or if the Israeli soldiers are bold/dumb enough to mistreat them with somebody like us watching, there will be recorded data on it, which will be presented to the world, which will ultimately help the Palestinian cause.
It's also quite easy to argue that the sheer existence of the checkpoints amounts to a gross violation of Palestinian rights, but unfortunately, the public discourse—similar to the limited focus on illegal settlement growth rather than illegal settlement existence—is not quite at this level yet.
Despite the fact that the soldier had told the Machsom writer that the police were on their way, she stood there unflinchingly. She warned us to step aside if we wanted to avoid any implication if the police did arrive.
At this point I was a fierce admirer of these women.
Fortunately, we stayed only another fifteen minutes and left. We repeated the process at another checkpoint, and then we were back on the road to Zaa’tara Junction, where we would catch a service taxi to Ramallah. What a day.
A special thanks to friend and expert baller Paul Notar for these photos.Note: the Machsom photographer's excellent pictures - all relating to Israel, Palestine, and the Occupation - can be found at www.activestills.org.